top of page

"From Business School Dean to Prison: The Dark Price of University Rankings"

In the competitive world of academia, a disturbing trend has emerged that threatens the foundation of educational integrity. Universities, long revered as bastions of knowledge and truth, are now scrutinised for participating in a deceptive game: manipulating rankings to enhance their prestige.

Columbia University’s Ranking Scandal

Columbia University plummeted from second place to 18th in the US News Rankings after one of its own Professors exposed that it had submitted false data. The zenith of the U.S. News & World Report’s rankings illuminates a troubling trend. The esteemed Ivy League institution admitted to employing "outdated and incorrect methodologies" following a faculty-led investigation that exposed significant data discrepancies. But Columbia’s fall from grace is merely a headline in a series of academic deceptions.

Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics

To inflate their SAT statistics, Baylor University offered financial incentives to students for retaking the SATs. Meanwhile, Clemson University was caught manipulating financial information and ranking assessments. The once-quiet corridors of Claremont McKenna College and Iona College echoed with admissions of SAT scores and admissions data falsifications. George Washington University and Emory University joined this hall of shame, admitting to inflating their reported statistics.

From Professor to Prison

More recently, former Temple Fox Business School Dean Moshe Porat was sentenced to 14 months in prison for charges that he conspired and schemed to deceive the school’s applicants, students, and donors into believing that the school’s business degree programs legitimately earned top rankings so that they would pay tuition and make donations to Temple.

Relying on the false information it had received from Fox, U.S. News ranked Fox’s OMBA program Number One in the country four years in a row (2015 – 2018). U.S. News also moved Fox’s PMBA program up its rankings from No. 53 in 2014 to No. 20 in 2015, to No. 16 in 2016, and to No. 7 in 2017. Finally, the defendant boasted about these rankings in marketing materials directed at potential Fox students and donors. Enrollment in Fox’s OMBA and PMBA programs grew dramatically in a few short years, which led to millions of dollars a year in increased tuition revenues.

Rethinking the Value of Rankings

These instances are not mere outliers; they represent a pervasive culture where universities have shifted their focus from educating minds to gaming systems. The ranking system, intended to guide students towards informed decisions, has been weaponised. In their quest for a higher rung on the prestige ladder, universities have engaged in a game of smoke and mirrors, prioritising appearance over substance.

The consequences are far-reaching. Prospective students make life-altering decisions based on manipulated data, trusting these institutions to act as beacons of truth. Alum pride and donations are solicited under false pretences. Academic missions are distorted as resources are funnelled not into educational quality but into crafting a deceptive narrative of excellence.

The revelation of these practices has sparked a much-needed debate on the purpose and integrity of higher education. It is a call to action for universities to reflect on their values and for ranking bodies to reconsider their methodologies. It is a wake-up call for society to question the metrics we measure educational success.

The time has come for a reckoning. We must challenge the status quo and demand transparency and accountability from our academic institutions. We must redefine the success metrics, emphasising the quality of teaching, research impact, and contributions to society over numerical rankings.

The ranking scandals are symptomatic of a deeper malaise—a crisis of identity and purpose within higher education. All stakeholders—students, faculty, alums, and administrators—are incumbent upon collective soul-searching. We must restore the foundational principles of education: honesty, inquiry, and the relentless pursuit of knowledge.

2,901 views0 comments


bottom of page